Vasudevan Software, Inc. v. MicroStrategy, Inc., No.
2014-1194, and Vasudevan Software, Inc. v. TIBCO Software,
Inc., No. 2014-1096, 2015 U.S. App. LEXIS 5396 (Fed. Cir. Apr.
3, 2015) (Linn, CJ.). Click Here for a copy of the
opinion.
Vasudevan Software, Inc. ("VSi") sued MicroStrategy,
Inc. ("MicroStrategy") and TIBCO Software, Inc.
("TIBCO") (collectively, "defendants") in
separate suits for infringing four U.S. patents. The patents shared
a common specification related to online data processing from
incompatible databases. The district court did not consolidate the
suits, but considered the claim construction issues together.
An issue arose over the term "disparate . . .
databases." The parties agreed that "disparate"
means "incompatible," but differed over how extensive
that incompatibility must be. VSi argued that the plain and
ordinary meaning of "disparate databases" is
"incompatible databases having different schemas." In
support, VSi cited testimony from