CAFC Holds PTAB Joinder Decisions Reviewable
Back in March, the Windy City panel
(Prost, Plager, and O'Malley) originally
held that § 315(c) was unambiguous that an existing
"party" to a PTAB proceeding cannot be joined as a
party. Thereafter, the SCOTUS considered the scope of
the PTAB appeal bar in its Thryv decision, holding that
potential violations of § 315(b) were too closely related to
the institution determination of the agency to escape §
314(d)'s appeal bar.
Last week, in view of Thryv, the Federal Circuit
modified its opinion in Facebook, Inc. v. Windy City
Innovations, LLC to make clear that joinder issues were
outside of the appeal bar.
In so holding (
here), the Court explained that § 315(c)
joinder includes two agency decisions: