On September 5, 2012, ALJ Pender granted respondents Sony Corporation and Sony
Corporation of America's (collectively "Sony")
motion for termination of Inv. No. 337-TA-807, Certain Digital
Photo Frames and Image Display Devices and Components Thereof,
based upon entry of a consent order. Complainant Technology
Properties Limited, LLC ("TPL") opposed the motion on
several grounds, including an objection based on a six-month grace
period to conduct infringing activities sought by Sony. ALJ
Rogers noted that whether a grace period was proper where a motion
for termination was opposed, was a matter of first impression.
He held that on the facts of this case, a six-month grace
period based on a date specific and not dependent upon the
occurrence of an uncertain event in the future was proper.
However, the opinion explicitly acknowledged that the issue
of whether such a grace period is proper when a motion to terminate
based on a consent order is opposed "may be a matter