The filed rate doctrine holds that the reasonableness of
insurance rates filed with and approved by a state insurance
regulator cannot be challenged in court. That doctrine ought
to apply even when the cost of the insurance is passed on, or
"secondarily billed," by the insured to its own
customers. After all, if the rate itself is reasonable (as
the filed rate doctrine holds), then it should not cease to be
reasonable simply because it is passed on to someone else.
However, a judge in the United States District Court for the
Southern District of New York recently held that the filed rate
doctrine does not apply to secondarily billed rates.
The case, Rothstein v. GMAC Mortgage,
LLC, is one of many involving force-placed hazard
insurance. Under the terms of most home mortgage loans, a
borrower is required to maintain hazard insurance on the mortgaged
property. If the borrower allows the policy to lapse, the
lender typically has the right to purchase such