In October 2017, the New York State Department of Financial
Services (DFS)
announced sweeping new regulations aimed at curtailing
marketing expenses, such as meals and sporting events, that title
companies ultimately pass on to their customers.
The regulations were quickly challenged in court by the New York
State Land Title Association (“the Association”) on
behalf of the title insurance industry, who argued that DFS
exceeded its authority when promulgating the regulations. In July
2018, Judge Eileen A. Rakower of the New York State Supreme Court
found in favor of the Association and annulled
the regulations. Judge Rakower found that the regulations
issued by DFS had exceeded the intent of the statute,
calling it an “absurd proposition” to suggest that
the Legislature intended to “prohibit title insurance
corporations from marketing themselves for business.”