The Issue: A terminated employee makes a claim
against the employer for damages. The company says it fired him for
stealing from the company. He says it was in retaliation for
reporting law violations by the employer (that is, for being a
whistle blower). At the same time, he files a claim for his
benefits under the company's 401(k) plan. Does the plan have to
pay him out?
The Solution: Yes. The fact that the company
feels wronged by the employee – for the theft and possibly
for alleging that it violated the law – is irrelevant. The
employee's benefits are still protected and must be paid.
Analysis: This issue is one of the most
disconcerting for employers. We often get the question, "you
mean we have to pay this [bad actor] his benefits even though he
stole from us and is trying to ruin our reputation?" No matter
how much we may empathize, we still have to give the client the
answer they don't like: yes, you have to pay out the
benefits.