The economic devastation wrought by COVID-19 has prompted
legislative, regulatory, and litigation efforts to tap insurance
coverage. On March 16, 2020, Oceana Grill in New Orleans filed the
first reported declaratory judgment action seeking coverage for
losses sustained due to the ongoing pandemic. The insured asserts
that coverage is available due to action by civil authorities
ordering closure of the restaurant. Other suits have followed,
including a California action by restaurants affiliated with Thomas
Keller, and an Oklahoma action commenced by Native American tribes
confronting lost casino revenue. Resolution of the litigated claims
will turn on policy language, as well as law and facts specific to
the jurisdiction. The threshold issue in most if not all such cases
will be whether COVID-19 constitutes direct physical loss or damage
to property. Generally, coverage under a property insurance policy
depends upon such a showing. Unless the insured can