The COVID-19 pandemic has unquestionably had a massive effect on
nearly all aspects of American life. However, now that
COVID-19 is and continues to be a known risk, parties should
carefully consider when and to what extent it can be invoked to
obtain an extension or continuance with respect to discovery
obligations.
This was recently demonstrated by Sunstate Equipment Co., LLC v.
EquipmentShare, in which the District of Utah held that
the defendant, EquipmentShare, could not stay already noticed,
in-person depositions by simply pointing to the COVID-19
pandemic. In late November 2020, the plaintiff, Sunstate
Equipment Co., LLC, sent deposition notices to EquipmentShare
seeking in-person testimony of EquipmentShare's witnesses at
Sunstate's counsel's office. In response,
EquipmentShare moved for a protective order seeking to delay the
in-person depositions as-noticed and requesting certain
depositions, in the meanwhile, to be conducted remotely from its
counsel's