In Williams v. Duke Energy Corp., Case No. 1:08-cv-46
(S.D. Ohio March 13, 2014), the U.S. District Court for the
Southern District of Ohio certified a class of direct purchasers of
electricity. The class alleged that a power company settled
objections of certain large customers to a rate-stabilization plan
in return for unlawful and substantial rebates to those customers.
Plaintiffs brought fraud and related claims on behalf of all
electricity purchasers who did not receive the rebates, and brought
Robinson-Patman Act price discrimination claims on behalf of
competitors of the favored businesses. In certifying the
Robinson-Patman competitor subclass, the Court noted that although
Robinson-Patman Act claims are generally not susceptible to class
treatment because of the individualized proof required to establish
damages, the plaintiffs in the case were seeking only injunctive
and declaratory relief under the Act, so competitive injury need
not be demonstrated.