Criminal Charges For Executive Stemming From Discovery Responses In DOJ Civil Antitrust Litigation

On October 14, 2016, former vice president and director of information technology of Coach USA, Inc. (Coach), Ralph Groen, entered a guilty plea for concealing and attempting to destroy documents and giving false and misleading statements under oath in a deposition during the US Department of Justice Antitrust Division's (DOJ) investigation of a joint-venture involving Coach.

The DOJ's complaint alleged that despite two preservation notices issued by Coach to its management team, which included Groen, Groen directed subordinates to destroy month-end backup tapes of emails and electronic records. Due to the destruction, the records were not produced to the United States during discovery. The government argued that these materials were relevant and responsive to the DOJ's discovery requests. Additionally, Groen then falsely informed the company's outside counsel that these materials did not exist. Groen also concealed versions of backup procedure documents that would