The Seventh Circuit Court of Appeals has found that an automated
text messaging system that dials from a stored list of numbers (but
does not generate random or sequential telephone numbers) is not an
Automatic Telephone Dialing System under the Telephone Consumer
Protection Act. Thus, no TCPA liability exists for these
texts. The case is Gadelhak v. AT&T.
The Seventh Circuit’s analysis largely joins that of the
Third, Eleventh, and DC Circuits. The Ninth Circuit’s
contrary decision in Marks v. Crunch is now a lone voice
in the TCPA wilderness.
Like other courts, the Seventh Circuit noted that the
plaintiff’s interpretation would create TCPA liability for
essentially every text message sent, including from an
iPhone. At the end of the day, however, the statute’s
nearly 30-year-old definition just does not include today’s
predominant messaging technology.