Share on LinkedInShare on LinkedIn

ARTICLE · 19 DECEMBER 2011

Refusal To Mediate Affects Costs Entitlement

The Court of Appeal, in its February 2011 judgment in the case of Rolf –v- De Guerin has taken the opportunity to reiterate that the conduct of parties during litigation, and in particular a refusal to mediate or attempt other forms of alternative dispute resolution, will have a significant impact on the costs award at the end of a case.

United KingdomLitigation, Mediation & Arbitration
Sue O'Brien
Sue O'Brien

Courtesy of Oxford Mediation

The Court of Appeal, in its February 2011 judgment in the case of Rolf –v- De Guerin has taken the opportunity to reiterate that the conduct of parties during litigation, and in particular a refusal to mediate or attempt other forms of alternative dispute resolution, will have a significant impact on the costs award at the end of a case. The well known 2002 case of Dunnett –v- Railtrack Plc established that a party who refused to mediate, even if successful in litigation, may not be awarded costs. This was clarified somewhat in 2004 in Halsey –v- Milton Keynes NHS Trust which set out the factors which a Court should take into consideration in deciding whether or not a party had unreasonably refused to mitigate. The non-exhaustive list of considerations included whether a case was intrinsically unsuitable for mediation (very few cases would fall into this category), the merits of the case and in particular did a party reasonably believe it

We operate a free-to-view policy, asking only that you register in order to read all of our content. Please login or register to view the rest of this article.

See more popular content from