Background
In complex international criminal investigations it is
invariably true that relevant – often electronic –
evidence is held overseas. There is often no effective way for law
enforcement authorities to obtain such evidence other than by
mutual legal assistance ("MLA"). The MLA process is,
however, cumbersome and can take months or even years to produce
results. It is therefore unsurprising that law enforcement
authorities are increasingly seeking new domestic powers to bypass
the traditional MLA process.
In the UK, a recent example is the decision in R (on the
application of KBR Inc.) v Director of the Serious Fraud
Office, which established that, in certain circumstances, the
Serious Fraud Office ("SFO") can compel the production of
documents held overseas by a company with no presence in the UK. In
that case, a representative of KBR Inc. (the US parent company of a
UK suspect, KBR Ltd.) was issued with a notice under section 2(3)
CJA 1987 whilst