Introduction
This is the third year that the authors have contributed a
chapter on energy arbitrations to this publication. It would be an
understatement to suggest that 2016 and 2017 were volatile years in
this respect. However, 2018 not only followed that pattern, but
represented one of the most seismic periods for the practice of
European investor–state arbitration.
In 2016, the first award against Spain, in respect of dozens of
claims it faces concerning changes to legislation regarding its
renewable power industry between 2010 and 2012, was seen in
Charanne BV and Construction Investments SARL v Kingdom of
Spain (Arbitration No. 062/2012). While Spain was successful
in that case, the respite was short as 2017 brought with it a
defeat in Eiser Infrastructure Limited and Energia Solar
Luxembourg Sarl v Kingdom of Spain (ICSID Case No.ARB/13/36)
(although Spain succeeded in defeating a similar claim in
Isolux Netherlands, BV v Kingdom of Spain (SCC