Arbitration awards are meant to be final and binding. Under the
rules of many of the leading arbitral institutions such as the ICC
and the LCIA, the parties give up any right to appeal the award on
the merits. But parties do retain a right to challenge an award if
there has been a violation of due process. Under English law,
a due process challenge is governed by Section 68 of the
Arbitration Act 1996, which requires the challenging party to prove
that there has been a ‘serious irregularity’.
One of the examples of such an irregularity given in the statute
is a ‘failure by the tribunal to deal with all the issues put
to it’. Unsuccessful parties have latched on to this,
challenging awards on the basis that the tribunal forgot to discuss
or expressly dismiss one of their arguments or simply preferred the
other side’s evidence without explaining why. Some
challenges have steered close to asking the court to review the
tribunal’s reasoning. In UMS Holding Ltd v