For some time, there has been a practice of issuing a so-called “Mareva by letter” to banks in respect of client funds to which a wronged third-party claims to have a right. A “Mareva by letter” seeks to put a bank on notice of fraud or other proprietary claims in order to freeze funds without the wronged party having to apply for a freezing order or proprietary injunction. A recent decision of the Sheriff Appeal Court of Scotland in the case of Bibby Factors Ltd v Bank of Scotland Plc [2026] SAC (Civ) 66, which applied many of the principles developed in the English Courts regarding fiduciary duties and accessorial liability, suggests that this is a risky strategy.
Background
The Claimant company, Bibby Factors Ltd (“Bibby”), was engaged in the provision of debt-factoring services, providing funding facilities to customers in return for an assignment to Bibby of the right to recover the customer’s outstanding debts. Each Bibby customer undertook to account to Bibby for any payment