On 31 October, the Dusseldorf Local Division issued its
decisions on the matter of preliminary injunctions requested by
Valeo Electrification against three companies in the Magna group,
citing infringement of two of their European patents.
In their defence, Magna claimed that the injunctions should not
be granted, in part because Valeo were supposedly not entitled to
commence proceedings under the patent. Magna argued that the
subject matter of the patents had been unlawfully extracted from an
earlier collaboration between Valeo and Magna, and that Valeo were
not entitled to the patents under which the actions were
brought.
The UPC is not in itself competent to hear entitlement actions,
and so the question as to whether Valeo are entitled to ownership
of the patent will eventually have to be addressed in the national
Courts in which the patent is in force. However, the decision on
whether to grant a preliminary injunction requires that it is more
likely than not