The inconsistency in the EPO Boards of Appeal in the problem of
assessing partial priority has been recognised and is being
referred to the EPO Enlarged Board of Appeal.
When going through the process of trying to get a patent for an
invention, it is quite common for a first application to be filed
that defines the invention in narrow terms, after which a second
application is filed, claiming priority to the first, describing
and claiming the invention more broadly. Under European law, this
would not normally result in any problems, provided there is no
intervening disclosure of the invention outside the narrow scope of
the first application. Some examples where this would be the case
are: i) the first application describing a specific chemical
compound, while the second claims a broader class of compounds; ii)
the first application describing a narrow range of parameters,
which is broadened in the second application; and iii) the first
application describing a