Patent attorneys have long advised their clients to focus on the
issues at the heart of a dispute and not to throw in a
"kitchen sink" of other complaints just because it is
easy to do so. In the patent case discussed below, ConvaTec face
costs assessed on the defendants spend of more than £6
million because they had included allegations of misuse of
confidential information before they had established that they had
cause to complain.
In a judgement which has now been upheld on appeal, see [2012]
EWCA Civ 520, ConvaTec failed to establish that a Smith &
Nephew wound dressing called Durafiber infringed their patent.
However, Claim 3 of the patent was found to be valid. Before the
case came to trial allegations in respect of other patents were
withdrawn and ConvaTec discontinued a claim against all of the
defendants, including an individual, Dr Stephen Law, for breach of
confidence and misuse of confidential information.