On 12th November 2002, we reported the ECJ decision in the Arsenal v. Reed case. It seemed that the ECJ had given a definitive ruling in Arsenal’s favour and a judgment that would make it easier for brand owners to prevent the sale of "unofficial" merchandise. After this ruling, many assumed that the High Court would treat the granting of an application by Arsenal for a permanent injunction as a formality. Laddie J.’s decision of 12th December 2002 proved them wrong.
Background
The case concerned the sale by Mr Reed of football souvenirs and memorabilia bearing the marks "Arsenal", "Gunners" and the cannon and crest logos – all of which are registered trade marks belonging to Arsenal F.C. Arsenal sued Mr Reed for trade mark infringement under section 10(1) of the Trade Marks Act 1994 – that is, use by Mr Reed of signs identical to its registered trade marks for goods identical to those in respect of which it registered the marks.