In what may come as a welcome departure from existing practice,
an EPO board of appeal in decision T1085/13 has clarified the
conditions under which patents can be granted for known compounds
at higher grades of purity.
A leading case concerning purity of materials has been T990/96
where it was held that a document disclosing a compound for the
first time ordinarily makes the compound available in all desired
grades of purity. EPO practice has been to view the earlier
disclosure as novelty destroying to a later claim in which
the same compound is claimed at a higher purity. To take an
example, a document discloses a new dye, which is manufactured in
90% purity. The position based on T990/96 is to assume that that
dye can be purified to all levels of purity by conventional methods
and so is made available to the public in all desired grades of
purity. Consequently, a later application claiming that dye in 95+%
purity would lack novelty over the earlier disclosure.