This article examines where we are with stress at work claims
following a series of cases in 2007/2008 which were seen to be
unhelpful to defendants.
The well known case of Hatton (2002) Court of
Appeal was seen by many employers as a blast of common
sense from the Court. Lady Justice Hale set out guidelines
which, it was supposed, if followed, would make an employer immune
from workplace stress claims. But, Lady Justice Hale only
ever intended her list to be guidance so, when a number of later
cases seemed to weaken the position for defendants, in fact all
that was happening was the clarification and application of the
principles which was probably always intended.
The panacea by which many employers thought they could discharge
their duty of care in all cases was by the provision of a
helpline. Lady Justice Hale had stated "An employer who
offers a confidential advice service, is unlikely to be found in
breach of duty". The existence of such a helpline