The judgment of Mr Justice Evans-Lombe handed down on 20 March 2002,
allows the proceedings brought by Baring Futures (Singapore) (“BFS”)
against Deloitte & Touche (Singapore) (“D&T”), its former
auditors, to proceed to full trial in May of this year. However, the
judgment itself has some important implications for companies, for
auditors and for insolvency practitioners in terms of representations
given to auditors by representatives of a company.
As a preliminary issue, D&T had argued that the claim against them
in respect of the 1992 and 1993 audits of BFS was bound to fail as, in
both of these audits, they had relied on representation letters addressed
to them and signed by the Finance Director of BFS, Mr Simon Jones. Mr
Jones, they said, had signed these letters recklessly and thus
fraudulently and it amounted to deceit. D&T said that this provided
them with a complete defence