It promised so much. At long last, a South African court ruling
on the patentability of computer programs. And a ruling on the
patentability of business methods. But in the end the case of
Standard Bank and MTN v 3MFuture proved to be something of
a damp squib.
The facts were quite simple. An inventor devised and patented a
'Transaction Authorisation System' that was
designed to solve the problem of bank card fraud in transactions,
particularly but not necessarily where the card holder and the
supplier are in different locations. He met with Standard Bank on a
number of occasions, seemingly with a view to selling or licensing
his technology, but no deal was done. Standard Bank subsequently
partnered with MTN to form a company called MTN Mobile, which used
technology that the inventor felt infringed his patent. So the
inventor, who had transferred his rights to 3MFuture, sued for
patent infringement. Standard Bank and MTN defended the action by
claiming that the