Overview
Most trade marks comprise a name or a logo, but in this
Singapore trade mark application, Ferrero S.P.A. sought to register
a "3-dimensional ball shape chocolate wrapped in a golden
foil, with a white sticker on top of the chocolate and resting in a
brown and gold striped paper cup" (Mark). To facilitate
visualisation of the Mark, this image was provided:

Did the Mark have distinctive character?
During the examination process, an objection had been raised on
the basis that the Mark was not distinctive and would not be
perceived as a badge of origin. Ferrero S.P.A. (Ferrero) requested
a hearing to pursue the application.
At the hearing, the adjudicator upheld this objection. He
characterised the Mark as a "composite mark" combining 3D
shapes, aspects of packaging, and colours. In his view, the gold
spherical ball shape was the main feature of the Mark, and lacked
distinctiveness as the shape and colour appeared to be commonly
used for chocolates.