ArticleHow Cool Is That Design? Community Registered Designs Under The SpotlightIn the latest legal battle between Apple and Samsung over tablet computers, Samsung won in court. United KingdomIntellectual PropertyBeck Greener
ArticleThe Patents County Court Flexes its MusclesIn the United Kingdom the Patents County Court is enjoying a renaissance under the control of its new judge His Honour Judge Colin Birss QC. United KingdomIntellectual PropertyBeck Greener
ArticleIs It Plausible? EPO Proceedings Stayed After Referral To Enlarged Board Of AppealThe EPO has paused all proceedings where the determination of whether an invention contains an inventive step is solely reliant on data that was not publicly available at the filing date...United KingdomIntellectual PropertyBeck Greener
ArticleThe Flip-Over First Class Seat - Or – Divisions In Patent ClaimsVirgin had alleged that their European patent (UK) 1495908 was infringed by aircraft seats of Premium Aircraft. At first instance, the judge, Lewison J had held that Claim 1 was limited to seats having a "flip-over" construction in which self contained integers formed the bed. United KingdomIntellectual PropertyBeck Greener
ArticleWhat Constitutes Contributory Infringement of a Patent in the United Kingdom?In a recent case, the Court of Appeal has considered what constitutes contributory infringement. It has concluded that where the supplier knows that his product can, and probably will be modifed, to infringe, the supplier commits an offence.United KingdomIntellectual PropertyBeck Greener
ArticleWe Can See Clearly Now - Acuvue Oasys Contact Lens Patent Is InsufficientIn an extremely long decision ([2009] EWHC 1671 (Pat)), running to 356 paragraphs, and dated 10th July 2009, Kitchin J of the English Patents Court found European patent (UK) No. 0819258 of Novartis to be new, non-obvious and infringed by contact lenses called Acuvue Oasys sold by Johnson & Johnson. United KingdomIntellectual PropertyBeck Greener
ArticleObviousness - Recent Cases Of The Court Of AppealThe Court of Appeal has considered the obviousness of patents in two recent cases, and has underlined that there is no "obvious to try" test and in each case upheld the decision of the judge at first instance.United KingdomIntellectual PropertyBeck Greener
ArticleThe IPEC Drills Claydon On Disclosure Of An Invention By Prior UseThis decision tests the general principle of UK patent law that if an invention is ‘seen' before filing any patent application, it cannot be patented.United KingdomIntellectual PropertyBeck Greener
ArticleWho Wants To Be A Millionaire?Dr Duncan Kelly has just been awarded £1 million in compensation in a landmark judgement from Mr Justice Floyd in the English high court. United KingdomIntellectual PropertyBeck Greener
ArticleCase Law: A Review Of Selected Pharmaceutical Patents In The UK Courts During 2020Patents lie at the interface between technology and law. This article provides a critical review of four high profile cases from 2020 in which patents relating to pharmaceuticals were litigated in the UK Courts.United KingdomIntellectual PropertyBeck Greener
ArticleIncompetence Is Expensive - Salutary Lessons From The English CourtsTwo recent cases from the English courts provide timely reminders of the need for advisors not only to be competent, but also to have the relevant skills and expertise.United KingdomIntellectual PropertyBeck Greener
ArticleComputer Implemented Inventions In The UK: Clarity From The High Court?In a recent decision of the High Court, <em>Halliburton v Comptroller of Patents</em> ([2011] EWHC 2508), relating to the high-profile area of patent law (patentability of computer-implemented inventions), His Honour Judge Colin Birss has made some interesting and useful comments that can serve as a helpful guide to those seeking patent protection in this area.United KingdomIntellectual PropertyBeck Greener
ArticleThird Party Observations For PCT Applications, A New Opportunity To Adversely Affect A Competitor’s Patent ApplicationThird parties can now submit observations as to the patentability of pending international (PCT) patent applications.United KingdomIntellectual PropertyBeck Greener
ArticleObviousness In The United Kingdom - Levofloxacin From Daiichi Is Not ObviousConfirming that the Court of Appeal had not found Daiichi’s medicine, Levofloxacin, to be obvious, Jacob LJ commented “I am not sorry to reach this conclusion. United KingdomIntellectual PropertyBeck Greener
ArticleA Taste Of The Future?It is an exciting time for technical innovations in the food industry, in the UK, Europe and globally. United KingdomIntellectual PropertyBeck Greener
ArticleIs the Invention Obvious? The Approaches of the EPO and The English Courts ConsideredThe English Court of Appeal has suggested that the "Problem and Solution" (PSA) approach, much used by the EPO when considering obviousness, should be considered to be an "administrative tool" only which does not necessarily lead to the "correct" answer.United KingdomIntellectual PropertyBeck Greener
ArticleMore Changes At The European Patent OfficeFurther changes are occurring at the European Patent Office. United KingdomIntellectual PropertyBeck Greener
ArticlePart 36 Offers And Costs OrdersFollowing trial and judgement in patent infringement proceedings relating to aircraft seats, the matter came to a hearing as to costs and, in particular, as to whether there should be disclosure of a Part 36 offer. United KingdomIntellectual PropertyBeck Greener
ArticlePatent ChoicesAn inventor may wish to obtain patent protection to protect his invention. In a global economy, protection in more than one country may be necessary.United KingdomIntellectual PropertyBeck Greener