The Privy Council set aside an appeal challenging a winding up
order of a Mauritian company, Katra Holdings Ltd (the Company), and
the judgment of the Supreme Court (Civil Appeal Division) upholding
that order.
The case revolved around a bank loan which had been made as part
of a wider series of transactions in relation to a share sale
agreement. The main question was whether the loan, which was
governed by the law of one jurisdiction, was unenforceable by
reference to principles of public policy on the ground that part of
the arrangements was unlawful in another jurisdiction.
The Company, through its principal and an associated company
registered in India, sought to profit by gaining control of and
selling on to investors shares in a private Indian bank, called
Tamilnad Mercantile Bank Ltd ("TMB"). This involved
acquiring options (i) to purchase 95,418 shares in TMB, which
represented 33.6% of the issued and paid-up equity shares in TMB
and had been held in the