How Carter-Ruck & Amersi v SRA and Al Sadeq v Dechert may reshape the handling of SRA investigations
For lawyers defending SRA investigations, the recent privilege decisions do more than settle an abstract point of law. They have an impact on what the regulator can compel, how an allegation of iniquity may be framed, and how firms should build a defensible record in matters carrying SLAPP risk. Privilege may restrict the evidence available to the SRA, but it does not reduce the professional standard expected of the solicitor.
Two decisions, one practical tension
In Carter-Ruck Solicitors and Mohamed Amersi v Solicitors Regulation Authority Ltd [2026] EWHC 2416 (KB), the High Court held that section 44B of the Solicitors Act 1974 does not authorise the SRA to compel a regulated person to produce material protected by a client’s unwaived legal professional privilege. The ruling concerns compulsory production. It does not decide whether the underlying work amounted to misconduct or a