The judgment of C v D et al (judgment of 17 December 2025) in the Isle of Man provides trustees with the helpful confirmation that a trustee can seek the blessing of the Court of a decision to retain funds in circumstances where the trust faces potential future liabilities. Furthermore, it confirms the position that the applicable test in the Isle of Man for a trustee to retain funds in respect of potential future liabilities is that those potential future liabilities must be “more than merely fanciful”.
In this case, the Trustee (also referred to as Party C) was represented by Appleby (Isle of Man) LLC.
Party C is the Trustee of a discretionary trust governed by Isle of Man Law (referred to as the 2015 Trust). Parties A and B were beneficiaries of the 2015 Trust and Party D was a former beneficiary to whom assets had been appointed immediately prior to her exclusion. Having failed to agree a suitable indemnity with Party D, and knowing (on the basis of professional advice) that