Introduction
The Delhi High Court ("DHC")
delivered an important judgment in NTT Docomo Inc. vs. Tata
Sons Ltd.,1 in which it upheld an
award delivered by an arbitral tribunal in London, directing Tata
Sons Ltd. ("Tata") to pay NTT Docomo
("Docomo") INR 84.5 billion or about USD
1.34 billion2 as damages. The judgment is a
significant one as it drives home the issue of an Indian company
honouring its contractual obligations with a foreign company.
This newsletter summarizes the key points discussed in the
judgment that could impact contracts between an Indian and a
non-resident party.
1. Facts
In 2009, Docomo and Tata executed a Shareholders Agreement
("SHA") where the exit clauses entitled
Docomo to exercise a put option if Tata failed to perform certain
conditions. In that case it would be obligated to find buyers for
Docomo's shares at a sale price which was (i) the fair value of
the shares as of March 31, 2014; or (ii) 50% of the price at which
Docomo