Introduction
Nordic Intertrade As (Norway) v. Steel Authority of India
Limited1 , entailed a judicial challenge to a domestic
arbitral award involving liability for payment of export duty in an
FOB Contract. A Division Bench of the Delhi High Court in the
course of annulment proceedings had to interpret and apply the ICC
INCOTERMS 2000 to an FOB sale contract.
The Court whilst dismissing the challenge to the award, narrowly
construed the 'patent error of law' exception, by ruling
that this ground could only be availed of in limited circumstances,
where the findings by the tribunal were "manifestly contrary
to law". The Court explained that a plausible or even
erroneous legal finding made by the tribunal would not warrant
judicial review as judicial philosophy favoured a 'hands
off' approach to annulment proceedings.