The authors are Advocates at Karanjawala & Co. They
practice Arbitration as well as before the Hon'ble High Court
of Delhi.
If we believe that arbitrators are neutral, then the fact
that a third party did not get a chance to participate in the
constitution of the arbitral tribunal should not affect the
principle of equality between the parties.
The most valued aspect of arbitration is the ability of the
aggrieved parties to appoint and choose their own arbitral
tribunal.1 The necessity to give a
third party the right to participate in the constitution of the
tribunal has been considered one of the main problems regarding the
participation of third parties in international arbitration.2 In fact, this issue was at the core
of the Siemens v Dutco Construction Company Case.3 This judgment gave the status of
"public policy"4 to the
right of a party to participate in the constitution of its arbitral
tribunal.5 Some legal experts have
expressed concern that if a third