Introduction
The Consumer Protection Act, 1986 (CPA) confers exclusive
jurisdiction to designated consumer courts to determine by summary
procedure any dispute entailing a 'deficiency of service'
between a consumer and a service provider. The speedy disposal of
such proceedings incentivises many litigants to dress up commercial
disputes as one warranting consumer protection and attracting the
jurisdiction of the consumer courts. This inevitably gives rise to
tensions between the jurisdiction of the consumer courts and the
requirement to arbitrate contained in commercial contracts with
nice questions as to which prevails.
The Supreme Court in a recent review petition involving a
dispute between a builder and a purchaser of a villa, which dispute
provided for arbitration, refused a reference to
arbitration1. The Court regarded the purchaser as a
consumer for the purposes of the CPA. In the Court's view,
consumer disputes are non- arbitrable. This is on the