In a recent case a photographer authorized the operators of a
travel website to publish one of his photographs on their website.
A pupil at a secondary school in Germany downloaded that photograph
from the travel website (on which it was freely accessible) in
order to illustrate a school presentation, which was then published
on the school website. The photographer alleged that his copyright
was infringed by the school since he had given the right to use his
photograph only to the operators of the travel website.
In the context of a preliminary ruling, the Court of Justice of
the European Union (the Court) was asked by the German Supreme
Court to specify how to construct the concept of 'communication
to the public' within the meaning of the Copyright Directive of
2001 (the Directive). In a judgment issued in August 2018, the
Court reiterated that this concept includes two cumulative
criteria, namely an 'act of communication' of a work and
the communication of that