Reconsidering the Lasmos approach to winding-up petitions
involving arbitration clauses
For a second time in two months, the Hong Kong Court of Appeal
was asked to consider the correctness of the controversial approach
adopted in the case of Lasmos Limited v. Southwest Pacific
Bauxite (HK) Limited (2018) HKCFI 426 in dealing with
winding-up petitions involving arbitration clauses. The issue was
first brought to the Court of Appeal in the case of But Ka Chon
v. Interactive Brokers LLC [2019] HKCA 873, [2019] HKEC 2473
earlier in July this year. The Court of Appeal had then expressed
its reservations on the Lasmos approach but did not
finally decide on its appropriateness.
In the most recent case of Sit Kwong Lam v. Petrolimex
Singapore Pte. Ltd [2019] HKCA 1220, the Court of Appeal once
again did not find it necessary to decide on the correctness of the
Lasmos approach but warned against debtors’
opportunistic attempts to invoke the Lasmos approach in
future.