The presumption that "rational businessmen" intend all
their disputes to be resolved in the same forum may not apply where
the parties clearly intended otherwise. Construing such intentions
requires a "broad and commercially minded approach" to
inconsistent dispute resolution clauses.
In H v G [2022] HKCFI 1327, the Hong
Kong Court of First Instance set aside an arbitral tribunal's
determination that it had jurisdiction over claims under a warranty
where an associated contract contained the arbitration clause, but
the warranty itself provided for litigation in Hong Kong. This
decision underlines that there are limits to the Fiona
Trust presumption in cases where the parties' overall
contractual arrangements give rise to agreements containing
different dispute resolution provisions.