Cayman Islands Grand Court Confirms US$56 Fair Value in 58.com Appraisal Claim
In a significant decision for Cayman Islands appraisal jurisprudence, the Cayman Islands Grand Court (the “Grand Court”) has determined that the fair value of dissenting shareholders’ shares in 58.com, Inc. (the “Company”) was US$56 per American Depositary share (“ADS”) — the merger price — in proceedings brought following the Company’s US$8.7 billion management-led take-private transaction in September 2020 – the largest take-private transaction of a Chinese company at the time.
The judgment, delivered by the Hon. Justice Margaret Ramsay-Hale, Chief Justice of the Grand Court, comprehensively rejected the dissenters’ contention that the merger price should be given no weight and that fair value should instead be assessed at approximately US$105.78 per ADS (89% more than the merger price) based exclusively on a discounted cash flow (“DCF”) analysis.