Canadian Courts have always been reluctant to intervene in
arbitral decisions. Judicial intervention in an arbitration, either
by way of a review or an appeal from the arbitral award, undermines
the efficiency of the arbitration process. If parties could appeal
or apply to set aside every arbitral decision with which they
disagree, it would be more cost-effective to litigate their dispute
in the Courts. For this reason, judges are usually only willing to
intervene in an arbitration where the arbitrator's decision
raises a "true question of jurisdiction".
The issue of what constitutes a "true question of
jurisdiction" has plagued Canadian jurisprudence for some
time. As recently as 2018, the Supreme Court of Canada in
Canada (Human Rights Commission v. Canada (AG), 2018 SCC
31, noted that "true questions of jurisdiction" have been
on "life support" and that the existence of this category
of question has "long been doubted".