With the current strain on judicial resources, settlement is a
frequent (and frequently encouraged) conclusion to ongoing
litigation. In order to incentivise settlement out of court, the
concept of settlement privilege developed - the idea being that
negotiations will be more productive if parties know that their
discussions are without prejudice and cannot be subsequently
disclosed. What do you do, then, when there are settlements with
multiple parties and you may not want to disclose just how much (or
how little) you have settled for?
The Supreme Court of Canada recently addressed this issue in Sable Offshore Energy Inc v Ameron
International Corp. In this case, Sable Offshore Energy
Inc. ("Sable") sued a number of defendants who had
supplied it with paint intended to prevent corrosion of its
offshore structures. Sable entered into Pierringer Agreements with
all but two of the defendants. A Pierringer Agreement allows one or
more defendants in a multi-party