In Girao v. Cunningham, 2020 ONCA 260,
the Ontario Court of Appeal addressed several important issues
regarding trials, particularly in personal injury actions. These
issues include the use of joint document books; introducing
evidence of participant experts and non-party experts; the
distinction between section 35 and section 52 of the Evidence
Act; and advising the jury of accident benefits
settlements.
Background
The action arose out of a car accident in 2002. The plaintiff
alleged that she sustained pain in her back and neck that
eventually became chronic, as well as other symptoms, including
major depression. She was not able to continue with her job as a
cleaner.
The defendants' position was that the accident was minor and
did not cause the plaintiff's problems. They pointed to
pre-accident psychiatric issues. They also argued that the
plaintiff was a malingerer. They elicited evidence that the
plaintiff received more in a statutory accident benefits