As courts cautiously resume in-person hearings across the
country, there is looming uncertainty about when—or
if—civil jury trials will ever resume. For instance,
B.C. and
some regions in Ontario have announced that civil jury trials
are suspended until at least 2021—and Ontario is considering
whether to abolish them altogether. By contrast,
Alberta is allowing all jury trials to resume subject to new
health and safety protocols, but there has not been a civil jury
trial in Alberta in nearly a decade. Amidst all the changes to the
justice system that will be caused by the pandemic, the fate of the
civil jury trial is unclear.
Unlike in serious criminal cases, there is no constitutional
right to a civil jury trial in Canada, not even in very high-stakes
cases. Whether a civil jury trial is permitted depends on the
procedural rules of each province. The rules generally allow for
civil juries in cases of defamation, false imprisonment, or
malicious prosecution—and