Good afternoon.
Following are this week's summaries of the Court of Appeal
for Ontario.
In Armstrong v. Royal Victoria Hospital, the plaintiff was
seriously injured during a colectomy surgery. The trial judge found
the doctor who completed the surgery negligently caused the
plaintiff's injuries. The doctor appealed this liability
finding, arguing that the trial judge erred by (i) establishing a
standard of perfection; and (ii) conflating the causation and
standard of care analysis.
A majority of the Court of Appeal agreed with the doctor. In
clarifying the appropriate standard of care analysis, the majority
held that it will generally be an error of law to use outcomes or
goals as the standard of care. The trial judge measured the
doctor's liability according to the goal a prudent surgeon
would have when conducting the operation, rather than the means a
prudent surgeon would use to attain that goal. This was an error of
law.