Introduction
The Court of Appeal for British Columbia (the “Court of
Appeal”), in Neufeldt v. Insurance Corporation of
British Columbia, 2021 BCCA 327, recently provided significant
commentary on the important yet difficult issue of indivisible
injuries. Insurance Corporation of British Columbia (the
“Appellants”) appealed the British Columbia Supreme
Court's decision wherein the Honourable Mr. Justice Ball held
that the injuries Mr. Jeffrey Theodore Neufeldt (the
“Respondent”) sustained as a result of two separate
motor vehicle accidents were indivisible. Significant damages
were awarded as a result of the trial decision.
Brief Facts
The first motor vehicle accident occurred in September 2012 (the
“First Accident”) and the second in May 2016 (the
“Second Accident”). In the First Accident, the
Respondent was working as an RCMP officer and sustained injuries to
his neck and back with resultant headaches. Although he continued
to experience pain as a result of