A November 6, 2018, World Trade Organization (WTO) dispute
settlement panel report1 is further confirmation that
while safeguard actions are in principle permitted by WTO rules,
establishing compliance with those rules will be a daunting task
when a safeguard is challenged by other WTO Members.
The November 6 panel report is just the latest in a long line of
cases in which WTO Members have been unable to justify their
safeguard measures. The case involved a complaint by Japan
regarding a measure imposed by India on imports of hot-rolled flat
steel products. The panel found the adequacy of the explanations by
India's authority to be lacking, including with respect to the
existence of serious injury or threat of serious injury and the
causal relationship between the increase in imports and that
serious injury or threat.