The College of Physicians and Surgeons (the CPSO) recently
amended its policy "Planning for and Providing Quality
End-of-Life Care" in light of a decision of the Ontario
Superior Court in a medical malpractice lawsuit.
In the case of Wawrzyniak v.
Livingstone, the plaintiff, who was the substitute
decision-maker (SDM) for her father, alleged that her father's
physicians failed to meet an acceptable standard of care when they
made the decision to write a do not resuscitate (DNR) order without
her knowledge and consent in September, 2008. In August, 2019, her
lawsuit was dismissed and no appeal is being taken.
The foundational facts of the case involved a medical consensus
of a critical care physician and an internist, that the
patient's death was imminent (meaning within days), and that he
would almost certainly not benefit from aggressive ICU care or CPR,
which would only increase his suffering at the end of his life, and
co-signed a DNR order in his chart. One of