Some people are good for their word. Others are not. Depending
on the circumstances, a promise you make may not be legally
enforceable. However, in the words of the outgoing Chief Justice of
the Supreme Court of Canada in the recent judgment in Cowper-Smith v
Morgan, 2017 SCC 61, equity enforces promises that the law
does not.
That case involved a promise made by a sister to her brother in
the context of making arrangements for the care of their elderly
mother. The Court was asked to consider whether the doctrine of
proprietary estoppel bound the sister to her promise after the
mother's death.
At a very high level, the mother's will gifted her estate
equally to her three children. At some point, the mother became
unable to live on her own and care for herself. One son, Max, who
lived in England at the time, agreed to move back to British
Columbia to live with and care for his mother in her house. He did
so after his sister, Gloria, agreed that he would be entitled