In Lawen Estate v. Nova Scotia (Attorney General), 2019
NSSC 162 ("Lawen"), the Nova Scotia
Supreme Court found that the Nova Scotia dependants' relief
legislation violated s. 7 of Canada's Charter of Rights and
Freedoms (the "Charter").
Dependants' relief, or wills variation, legislation allows a
testator's spouse and children to apply for a court order to
vary the terms of the will on the basis that it did not provide
adequate maintenance and support for them.
The testator, Jack Lawen, had four children: three daughters and
a son. In his will, Mr. Lawen left two of his daughters gifts of
$50,000 each and the remainder of his estate to his son. His
daughters commenced a dependant's relief action. In response,
Mr. Lawen's executor and his son brought an application for a
declaration that certain sections of the Testator's Family
Maintenance Act (Nova Scotia)
("TFMA") that permit claims by
independent adult children violated Mr. Lawen's
Charter rights to freedom of