The BC Court of Appeal's decision in Kirk v Executive
Flight Centre et. al1 striking out certification of an
environmental class action illustrates the challenges in bringing
environmental torts by way of class proceedings and specifically
maintains a high bar for nuisance claims to be certified.
The defendant was driving a fuel truck when his truck rolled
down an embankment into Lemon Creek, spilling 35,000 litres of Jet
A-1 fuel. Local residents were ordered to evacuate, and water use
restrictions were issued. The plaintiff commenced a class
proceeding on behalf of local residents for claims including
negligence, nuisance and diminution of market value of properties.
The matter was certified as a class action, and the defendants
appealed on the grounds that the Judge erred in certifying several
common issues that lacked sufficient commonality.