In the long-awaited decision in the case of Orphan Well
Association v Grant Thornton Ltd, the Supreme Court of Canada
held that end-of-life environmental cleanup obligations imposed by
Alberta's provincial regulatory scheme on bankrupt oil and gas
companies take priority over all bankruptcy claims, including
secured creditor claims.
The trustee's disclaimer of a number of oil wells without
value to the bankrupt estate did not allow the bankrupt estate to
abandon its environmental cleanup obligations imposed under
Alberta's regulatory scheme with respect to those orphaned
wells. In so finding, the majority of the Supreme Court held that
the environmental obligations with respect to the orphaned wells
were not provable claims, and as such there was no conflict between
the provincial regulatory scheme and the provisions of the
Bankruptcy and Insolvency Act ("BIA").