This morning the Federal Court of Appeal (2018 FCA 153) quashed
the federal government's Order in Council approving the
TransMountain Expansion project. The court's reasons are
summarized in the following four paragraphs from its decision:
[4] While a number of applicants challenge the report of the
National Energy Board, as explained below, the Order in Council is
legally the only decision under review. Its validity is challenged
on two principal grounds: first, the Board's process and
findings were so flawed that the Governor in Council could not
reasonably rely on the Board's report; second, Canada failed to
fulfil the duty to consult owed to Indigenous peoples.
[5] Applying largely uncontested legal principles
established by the Supreme Court of Canada to the factual record, a
factual record that is also largely not contested, I conclude that
most of the flaws asserted against the Board's process and
findings are without merit. However, the Board made one